Penn National Withdraws Lawsuit Against Pa. Mini-Casinos - News : News
  • 3 minutes read
Published on
Update on

Casino operator Penn National Gaming Inc. confirmed this week that it had withdrawn its lawsuit against the Keystone State challenging the legalization and expansion of the so-called “mini-casinos”. Penn National went public with its objection to the new Category 4 casino licenses that authorized the establishment of new mini-casino in the state.

According to Penn National Gaming, the satellite casinos were very likely going to cannibalize the state’s existing set of casinos without contributing much to the revenue. The operator, through its lawyers, went further ahead to claim that Hollywood Casino at Penn National Race Course, its operation in the state, was going to be uniquely victimized particularly because the 24-mile buffer zones for existing casinos would provide huge buffers for its competitors but leave its more far-flung primary market exposed.

In addition to that, they also claimed the state law provided special treatment to Mount Airy Casino when it excluded the establishment of casinos within three of Mount Airy’s surrounding counties. Also, Mount Airy is not required to share a cut of their revenue with all the surrounding counties, unlike the case with the remaining 12 operators who are required to share portions of their revenue with the local host authorities. The operator’s lawsuit was championing for the federal courts to block the state’s new Category 4 casino provisions because they “treat existing operators unfairly and use ‘unconstitutional’ language.”

A Change of Heart?

Regardless of their stance against the state’s laws, Penn National went ahead to secure the rights to the first Category 4 auction – they paid a whopping $50.1 million for the rights to set up a mini-casino in York County. A while later when bidding for the remaining licenses stalled and previous auction winners were allowed back to the bidding pool, Penn went back for a second satellite, this time parting with a $10.5 million for Lancaster County.

Now, with the two Category 4 casino licenses in hand, the operator has opted to focus on the two projects instead of the fruitless fight against the inevitable development.

“We made a business decision to withdrawal our lawsuits against the Category 4 law. While we continue to believe in the merits of our arguments, we have chosen to focus entirely on our development efforts for our two new casinos, rather than pursue what is likely to be a lengthy and costly legal battle,” Eric Schippers, the Penn National spokesperson explained. “Our goal in pursuing our Category 4 licenses is both defensive, in terms of protecting our existing investment at Hollywood Casino from new competition, and offensive in terms of penetrating more deeply into more populous market areas to our south and east.”

As it stands, the casino operator is yet to name final site for either of its winning bids. It may not be late for this since the PGCB recently gave it a two-month extension to come up with a formal proposal for the site of the satellite casino in York County.

Editor's Picks

Online Gambling Finally Takes Off in Pennsylvania

Following several months of rigorous product testing by the Pennsylvanian Gaming Control Board (PGCB), three of the Keystone State’s licensed casino operators have recently begun offering their online gaming products to the state’s residents. Pennsylvania will now be finally joining the small list of states where online casino-style gaming is fully legalized and regulated. Penn […]

Pa. Casinos Lose Lawsuit Against Online Lottery Games

A while back, a coalition of seven casinos in Pennsylvania filed a lawsuit seeking an injunction to stop the Pennsylvania Lottery from offerings online casino-style games. Last Friday, the casinos were dealt a huge blow when a Commonwealth Court chose to side with the lottery. The Pennsylvania Lottery officially launched its online lottery product in […]

PGCB To Hold Casino License Auction in September

On Wednesday, July 10, the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board (PGCB) voted in favor of a plan to recommence the Category 4 satellite casino auction process. As such, the state will try again to award gaming licenses for five more satellite casinos as part of the ongoing aggressive gambling expansion that kicked off in October 2017. […]

Similar Stories in Gambling

Pennsylvania Slots Records Revenue Growth in Fiscal Year 2018/2019

The Keystone State’s slot machine revenue increased 1.1 percent during the just concluded 2018/2019 state fiscal year compared to the 2017/208 fiscal year. These figures were presented by the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board (PGCB) last Monday, the breakdown of the slot machine revenue figures has set the precedence for the total gaming report that is […]

SugarHouse Casino to Rebrand in the Fall

Philadelphia’s Sugar House Casino is soon set to rebrand as part of a series of upgrades that Rush Street Gaming, the property’s owner, has planned. This fall, the gaming and entertainment complex will officially change its name to Rivers Casino Philadelphia. As it turns out, these changes have been part of the company’s plans for […]

PGCB Approves the Sale of Sands Bethlehem to Wind Creek

Over a year after the deal was announced, the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board has finally approved the sale of the $1.3 Sands Casino Resort Bethlehem to an affiliate of an Indian Tribe. The transaction which was announced on Wednesday, May 29 by Wind Creek Hospitality which is affiliated to the Poarch Band of Creek Indians […]

Online Sports Betting Finally Arrives in Pennsylvania

It has been a long time coming but Pennsylvanian sports betting fans are now going to be able to place bets online. This news came on Tuesday, May 28 when the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board gave Philadelphia’s SugarHouse Casino the green light to launch its online sports betting offering making is the very first casino […]